Gulfport Energy

Why I bought shares

Published on:
May 26, 2019
Last Update:

Written by

Noam Ganel is the voice behind Pen & Paper, a value-oriented stock research publication. He  serves as  Vice President in Capital Markets at Silvergate Bank and holds the Chartered Analyst Credential (CFA).

"Four bucks a gallon - that's insane!," said Jim, a colleague. "My commute is over 25 miles each way. Let me tell you Noam, and I did the math, my monthly gas bill just increased by $300."

I had no idea that gas prices were up. I often cycle to work and when I do drive a car, I rarely pay attention to the gas bill; the Subaru is gas-efficien enough. Intrigued byJim's lamentation, I went to the local gas station in California and saw that a gallon of gas, indeed, now costs $4.55.

A raising gas price is a business problem[1] for certain industries. So I returned to my desk and looked for publicly-traded companies that explore, develop and sell the commodity.

What gas companies are selling for

The initial results were unexciting. WPX Energy (WPX on Nyse), a natural gas liquidity company with market capitalization of $5,230 million, traded at 23 times the trailing earning and at a 20% premium to reported book value.

Cabot Oil & Gas (COG on Nyse), with a market capitalization of $11,000 million, traded at a more reasonable, 15 times the trailing earnings but at a whopping 5 times the reported book value.  

QEP Resources (QEP on Nyse)market capitalization of $1,760 million, was slightly at a discount to book value. But QEP reported losses in 2018, 2016 and 2015.

So did Oasis Petroleum (OAW on Nyse). With a market capitalization of almost $2,000 million, the company traded at par but reported losses in 2018, 2016 and 2015.

Frustrated for wasting two hours of sifting through the financial statements of natural gas companies, I screened for companies - without a specific industry in mind - that traded at 90% below their-5 year stock price high[2].

_____
ADVERTISEMENT

Webflow is the way to design, build, and launch powerful websites visually — without coding. While working full-time, at nights I developed Pen & Paper using Webflow.Webflow empowers you to create for the web.

In their words: "In today's web, the means of production lie in the hands of the few. We want to change that, and help create a more beautiful, diverse web. We want to democratize access to the tools and knowledge required to build beautiful, well-coded websites, web apps, and - eventually - digital products of all kinds."

_____

Finding Gulfport Energy

One of the first companies that appeared on the list was Gulfport Energy Corporation (GPOR on Nasdaq). The stock traded as high as $75 in 2014 and was now exchanging hands for about $6 a share, a drop of over 90%. Curious to understand the reason for the sharp decline, I downloaded the 10-k report.

Gulfport's share price decline over past five years

I  learned three of three things: First was the reason for the decline in stock price. Over the past ten years the price dropped for all the commodities sold by Gulfport: Oil price per barrel is down to $49 from $68; natural gas price is down to 53 cents from 96 cents; and gas price is now $2.47 from $6.90.  

The second issue was that the company's assets wildly grew. Gulfport's total assets increased to $5.8 billion from $2.7 billion five years ago, a compounded growth of 16%. But the equity increased to $3.3 billion from $2.69 billion, a compound growth of 4% [3].

Third, management had repurchased the stock at $8.81 at the end of last year and had budgeted to buy additional stock, up to $200 million worth, in the next two years.

I estimate that the company may buyback the stock without incurring any debt, simply by using free cash flow and perhaps selling non-core assets, such as the 9,829,548 shares Gulfport owned in Mammoth Energy (TUSK on Nasdaq.)

Gulfport Energy 5-year financial results

A back of the envelope calculation tells us that just the share repurchase program may result in an increase of 30% to 50% from the current price of $7 (write to me if you would like to see how I calculated this).  

_____
ADVERTISEMENT

Founded in 2004, by Charlie Tian PHD, GuruFocus provides institutional-quality financial stock research for the individual investor.

GuruFocus hosts many value screeners and research tools and regularly publishes articles about value investing strategies and ideas. One of the features I use most is the 30-year financial information on businesses. Visit the 30-year analysis on Gulfport Energy to see more.

_____

The gatekeepers

Yet what stands between the investor, yours truly now owns 1,500 shares, and the income from the natural gas and oil reserves is a board of directors that could easily win the worse capital allocator award, if there ever was one.

Since 2010 Gulfport’s board issued 138 million shares (read: diluted shareholders) at weighted price of $30. Since 2010, the company added to its equity base $3.19 billion; now the entire company can be bought for $1.19 billion, about a third of the price.

Surprisingly, perhaps, half of the board, four of the available eight board seats, is still running the show. Mr. David Houston has been a director since 1998. Mr. Ben Morris has been with the company since 2014. Mr. Craig Groeschel has been with the company since 2011. Mr. Scott E. Streller has been with the company since it became publicly traded in August 2006. As I wrote in A Docile Animal in Captivity, it is not easy to replace the gatekeepers - even ones with such dreadful track records.

In an industry fraught with technical terms such as "Proved Reserved" (page 3 of the recent 10-k report) and "Midstream Gathering"(page 62 of the recent 10-k report), natural gas investors, by default, know less about the business than the gatekeepers.

There are also uncertainties that management cannot plan for but only react to. Among those include supply and demand imbalances and future regulatory and political changes.

***

Why is there such a wide gap between GPOR's market price and value? Why did investors not complain about the board’s dismal performance? The advent and popularity of passive[4] investing, I believe, is at fault.

Blackrock, via its iShares ETF product, owns 24 million Gulfport shares. Dimensional Fund Advisors, another ETF provider, owns 15 million Gulfport shares. The quantitative firm, LSV Asset Management, owns 9 million shares. In total, over 58 million shares (about 36%) of the available 159 million shares are owned by passive investment funds.

It is little surprise they haven't noticed the gap.

FOOTNOTES
[1] The legendary value investor, Phillip Fisher, once said that "The successful investor is an individual who is inherently interested in business problems.
[2] In other words if a stock reached $100 over the past 5 years and was now trading at $10 - it would appear on the list.
[3]This was a decent growth track record, especially when considering the company took an impairment loss (which reduced the equity balance) of $715 million in 2016 and $1.44 billion in 2015.  
[4] Passive investing is performed by those who track quoted prices, and not quoted values.